Digital eBook Readers vs Hardcover Books

65
rate or flag
Facebook
Pin It

By elayne001

For Christmas I received an Amazon Kindle. At first I was a little hesitant to use this new technology, but since have come to embrace it. There are a few advantages to having an E-Book Reader, but I know that some prefer the feel, smell and look of their stacks of paperbacks, hardbacks and magazines in their home.


For sure, I am more aware of the number of books I have collecting dust on my shelves and end tables. I think, gosh, I could have a garage sale, and make a little bit of cash to download some more publications onto my kindle. I would have much more room in my home, less to dust and definitely less clutter. But will it affect me negatively in other ways?

When I was growing up, I remember my parents wanting us to have the best and latest information to help with our school work and for personal development. My father made sure we had current encyclopedias, and no doubt spent quite a bit on them. My father still has bookshelves filled with these valuable books. It is sad to think they may all be replaced by a little book reader, and whatever else you can find online. My father is still an avid reader, and prefers the feel of the traditional book.

There are some books that I feel cannot be replaced by e-books. I guess those that I will definitely keep are my old yearbooks, family bibles, any inscribed books that were gifts from friends and family with their sentiments and thoughts,scriptures with my personal notes written in the columns, and of course family photo books (although I am collecting less and less of them all the time since digital photos are easily accessible nowadays).

I guess I am also sort of sentimental about books that I had that have special personal meaning to me. We have made several moves in our married life, and have always dragged along several boxes of books. Some of the books remind me of special times in the places we lived, and fond memories of our children reading and sharing them.

Recently I took a trip which took six hours one way on an airplane. I took along my new Kindle, and I enjoyed the fact that I could just carry it in my purse. It does not take up much room and is very convenient. It also holds several books that I have been able to download in only a few minutes for very reasonable prices. I found that the Kindle Store prices are usually discounted from what I have seen in retail book stores.

Another thing I was happy to find out is that the battery on the Kindle lasts a long time. With my ipod touch, it seems that the battery runs out very fast, but not the Kindle. I do not have experience with other e-readers, but so far, I am quite happy with my Kindle.

I was also pleasantly surprised that the Kindle Store offers free books and games to download onto your Kindle. I was totally absorbed in one book about paramedics and their crazy experiences. I was also excited to see that many of the classics are free on the Kindle Store.

One thing I was disappointed in with my new Kindle is the text to speech feature. I turned it on to try it, and the thing sounded so robotic, it really took the emotion and excitement of the book right out of me. I turned it off and probably will not use it again. I am sure there are some people who would appreciate it, but I am not one of them.

Another thing that I have enjoyed in the past, but which I will have to reassess is looking for old books at second hand stores. Will hard cover books and magazines become obsolete in the near future because of this new technology. I hope not, but it does not seem too far away.

Certain people seem to think the eReaders are soulless faux-literary technology, but I have come to see its purpose and usefulness for traveling. It would be harder to take along a hardcover book since it would take up more room and be heavier. I like the ease of turning the pages on the Kindle - barely have to move a muscle (getting lazier and lazier aren't we?).

Do you prefer an eReader or an old fashioned hard or soft cover book?

  • eReader
  • Book
See results without voting

Comments

breakfastpop profile image

breakfastpop Level 8 Commenter 12 months ago

I adore hardcover books and a have a library of books to prove it. I never thought I could adjust to an E-reader, but I am happy to say I was wrong. I have a NOOK and I love it.

Mentalist acer profile image

Mentalist acer Level 7 Commenter 12 months ago

I find the Kindle easier to read and on my eyes for longer sessions,but as a person who mostly depended on magazines,the Kindle I have is not as good as having the real magazine.;)

diogenes 12 months ago

I will NEVER buy one of these things...it's as bad as burning books! Now, if I got one for free...! But, seriously (as it's possible for me to ever be these days) I love the look of firelight and lamplight on my little library. Can one of these 'readers ever feel like a book, the familiarity of the shape, the index, the author's bio. Finally jumping into bed with a sigh and leaning back with my latest paperback (crime and detective, USA only), the taste of the first paragraph melting on my tongue. And all these books I have, going back 50 years, how could I ever replace that on the internet? Never say never, right? But I will say, doubtful...Bob

2besure profile image

2besure Level 5 Commenter 12 months ago

Digital books are the way of future. I guess I am an old dog, I rather read a hard cover book.

elayne001 profile image

elayne001 Hub Author 12 months ago

It is difficult for us "old dogs" to adjust to some of the new technology gadgets. Each has his or her own reasons and some may never make the change, but that is okay too. Thank you all for your welcome comments. Aloha.

Crewman6 profile image

Crewman6 Level 3 Commenter 12 months ago

Your'e absolutely right. I have thousands of books collected over years, and for the most part they live in storage boxes in my shed. I've tried to organize them so I can find any book quickly, but it's still such a pain, they mostly just sit unread. My Kindle makes it so easy to carry a portable library with me, and very easy to organize and access the collection. Ebook readers will never replace real books for me, but they are a wonderful option.

elayne001 profile image

elayne001 Hub Author 12 months ago

I agree Crewman6. We can still use both, thank goodness. Books and eReaders can compliment one another. Thanks for your comments.

2besure profile image

2besure Level 5 Commenter 12 months ago

I must admit, I have been tempted to buy a kindle.

elayne001 profile image

elayne001 Hub Author 12 months ago

I thought about buying a Kindle, but was glad I received it as a gift. Not sure I would have taken the plunge by myself. My kids are really into new technology and they try to keep my husband and I up to speed. Thanks for commenting 2besure.

ImChemist profile image

ImChemist 12 months ago

I like hardcover books more than digital!

2besure profile image

2besure Level 5 Commenter 12 months ago

You go Ms. 2011! You learned a new trick LOL!

prasetio30 profile image

prasetio30 Level 8 Commenter 12 months ago

Good information. I love the way you communicate this. We live in modern era, where everything related with technology. E-book, we may never thought about this thirty years ago. But now, it more improved from day by day. Don't forget that we live in digital era. Anyway, we can't forget about the hardcover books. Teacher and lecturers still use this to teach their student. Good information. Good bless you. Take care!

Prasetio

elayne001 profile image

elayne001 Hub Author 12 months ago

It is true that technology changes so fast with time prasetio30. We can choose whether to accept or reject it, but it doesn't stop progression. Thanks for commenting.

elayne001 profile image

elayne001 Hub Author 12 months ago

I like that 2besure - you called me Ms. 2011. Funny, but perhaps learning new technology does deserve a title at my age.

elayne001 profile image

elayne001 Hub Author 12 months ago

You are definitely not alone in that ImChemist - each to their own - glad we still have freedom of choice. Thanks for commenting.

Glenn Stok profile image

Glenn Stok Level 6 Commenter 12 months ago

It's funny but I still prefer to read a book on the printed page even though I am so used to reading on the screen of my desktop.

There is something to be said about eReaders. They do save the environment as less trees need to be destroyed to print books.

Oh, by the way, my iPod also needs to be charged often. The display draws a lot of power as compared to the Kindle's display. As for the robotic voice, the technology exists for better speech. I'm surprised they don't use a better one. My GPS doesn't not sound robotic.

Nice review. I voted up.

Peter Owen profile image

Peter Owen Level 1 Commenter 12 months ago

I don't think books will be obsolete. If there are no books,a danger here is being controlled by the tech company. They would have the ability to control what you a allowed to read (seletion), how much you will pay for it (you're committed to them), and can turn you off if they don't like your or your ideas. If there is not enough competition in book readers, we are going one step closer to Big Brother watching us at all times.

elayne001 profile image

elayne001 Hub Author 12 months ago

It is true, Glenn, that the eReaders save on trees and other resources. I guess the eReaders will improve with time, but can never replace books. I appreciate your welcome comments.

That is a sobering idea Peter. I hope it never happens! Thanks for your thoughtful comments. I hope we will continue to buy books even though we have book readers and other technology.

dallas93444 profile image

dallas93444 Level 6 Commenter 12 months ago

I do not think it is a "either, or" choice. Both will be with us. An example: TV, or movies...? In the beginning, the movie industry was up in arms about the cable industry and the networks replacing the establish Hollywood distribution systems for movies...

There is a place for both...

elayne001 profile image

elayne001 Hub Author 12 months ago

I just remember when I started backing up all my digital info on floppy and zip discs (which I still have). They are now absolete, so we can never be sure what may or may not be with us in the future - only time will tell. Thanks for the comments dallas93444. I do believe there is room for both, as you said.

Les Trois Chenes profile image

Les Trois Chenes Level 4 Commenter 12 months ago

The ladies at our book club in Limousin, France, love their Kindles. We formed to group to swap good books in English. Will add your article to my Hub about the pro's and cons of Kindle.

Hello, hello, profile image

Hello, hello, 12 months ago

Great hub with all pros and cons. Thank you.

elayne001 profile image

elayne001 Hub Author 12 months ago

That is great Les Trois Chenes. I appreciate that.

I learned through experience these pros and cons. I am sure there are many more that could be added. Thanks Hello, hello,

LianaK profile image

LianaK 12 months ago

Great commentary on the pros and cons of eReaders. I didn't think that I would like them initially, but they are beginning to grow on me. Thank you for the great Hub.

Brandy 12 months ago

I also got a Kindle for Christmas. I was really nervous about using it because of many of the reasons you listed. I would hate for REAL books to become obsolete. But, I have to say I absolutely love it. I don't have to carry around several books at once in case I get tired of reading one and want to switch. They are all there, in my hand.

elayne001 profile image

elayne001 Hub Author 12 months ago

Thanks LianaK. eReaders are great for students, I suppose. Much lighter than some of the textbooks they have to carry around. Thanks for your perspective.

So true, Brandy. I do like my Kindle for the same reason you do. Can carry many books at the same time. Appreciate your comment.

Website Examiner profile image

Website Examiner Level 6 Commenter 2 months ago

Interesting topic. I am only gradually coming to understand the e-book phenomenon, like Kindle, as I don't possess any such device. For me, an e-book is mostly a PDF file, which has formatting more similar to a real book. The magazines that I publish are also PDFs. Real e-books like those for the Kindle are supposed to be formatted in special ways, mainly that page numbers and headers etc. are stripped off.

Anyway, what I noticed was that you did not find the text-to-speech feature adequate. Maybe that has been improved, or will be. I use text-to-speech extensively on my PCs, where I have installed some of the most human-sounding voices available. I could not deal with a robotic sound.

elayne001 profile image

elayne001 Hub Author 2 months ago

Thanks for your ocmments Website Examine. I love my Kindle. I read myself to sleep with it every night. I know they have improved quite a bit on e-book readers - it is hard to keep up, but for now, I am quite pleased with mine. Aloha!

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    working